Tourist traps
While it is easy to find the top tourist destinations around the
world, the identities of their least popular counterparts are less
publicized; they remain hidden in lists of visitor statistics, buried
in the reams of numbers produced by the international tourist industry
groups. You have to look carefully for them - if you search on Google
for some of them, you get no hits. They have exited the global stage,
perhaps happily. But who knows? Their populace remains faceless
to global media, their cultures obscured by the glare of the Big
Tourist Destinations: France, Spain, the United States.
I am fascinated by the mirror pairs - the visited, visible tourist
destination and its corresponding, unseen twin. France and Tuvalu;
Spain and Kribati; the United States and Rwanda; Italy and Tiue.The
question is not, "why are some states never visited" -
the answers are obvious. The least visited countries are avoided
because they are small, or obscure, or instable. The question rather
should be, "what is the world we see through souvenir postcards?"
And: "what is the world that remains stubbornly unpictured?"
As such, Tiue and Kribati are more interesting than Rwanda or Afghanistan
(whose sister country is China). We know what Rwanda and Afghanistan
look like. We watch the evening news. But what about the countries
we never see at all, whose citizens, though affected by the policies
of the world powers, remain only abstractions?
The challenge that this map answers is this: how to visualize the
distance between the maximum and the miniscule? The scale itself
is enormous. For every one person who visits Sierra Leone, 1,800
visit Austria. How can we represent that space without resorting
to more picture postcards - iconic images that obscure instead of
revealing? Visitor statistics for the most visited countries are
available online - I know that most people who visit France see
Paris and the surrounding area, that the most visited area in Spain
is around Madrid, that Pompeii is actually Italy's most popular
tourist attraction (I suppose the Vatican does not count) and that
New York and Orlando battle it out for supremacy in the United States.
But I do not know how to appropriately represent Tuvalu, or Tiue,
or even Afghanistan. What is the most popular tourist attraction
in Rwanda? The final difference between big and little may be the
very stubborness with which the least visited countries resist the
very categories of visitation.
Addition: 10_15
One way perhaps to imagine this is to develop a correlative between
the "most visited" tourist spots and their virtual presences online.
If that's not comparing apples to oranges. Ie, it's very easy to
find info/pictures for France, Spain, the US, et cetera, but very
difficult to find any info at all on their sister countries. Perhaps
one way to get around this is to represent the "hidden"
countries with the (failed) results of Google searches - graphic
representation of the disappearance - or notoriety (in Rwanda's
case) - of these hidden countries from the invisible currents of
tourism, money, and prestige.
Addition: 10_17
As usual, we can look for some answers by returning to the source
of the question: the World Tourist Organization. They collect the
data, they analyze the results, they define the criteria by which
tourism is judged. They are the mirror through which, like Alice,
we must step to reach the upside-down wonderland of the invisible
countries. And what does the organization do? According to its website,
"Through tourism, WTO aims to stimulate economic growth and
job creation, provide incentives for protecting the environment
and cultural heritage, and promote peace, prosperity and respect
for human rights."
I n the right-side-up world of the WTO (an arm of the UN charged
with creating partnerships between UN countries and tourist businesses),
tourism is an agent for positive change. It is a savior of underdeveloped
countries, creating jobs, attracting foreign currency, and tying
the destination country more fully into the global culture. Being
glimpsed by foreigners gives these hidden countries a face, and
avoice, in the global market.
The power of this mirror rests in its ability to scale the world
to a manageable order. Like the representation of distance in the
Eames short film Powers of 10, the orders of magnitude
described by the scales of WTO reports are almost too great to visualize,
except in gradual degrees of change. And like Powers of 10,
the world seen in the mirror is almost unbearably orderly, with
the developed tourist powerhouses separated from the lowest ranks
of unvisited nations by a difference of size, not kind. The myth
behind Powers of 10 is that the structure of the universe
is masterable, symmetric, and understood. It asserts that the very
smallest particles and the very largest spaces share a common structure.
The myth behind the WTO rankings is that more tourists will turn
Rwanda into the US, Tiue into France.
The more I look at this project, the more I see a funny and tragic
commentary on the Powers of 10 myth of the world. When
we zoom out, the world looks more like Rwanda than Austria. It looks
more like Tuvalu than France - mostly because we don't even know
what Tuvalu looks like. Tuvalu is opaque and impenetrable. There
is no common tourist imagery yet. We have not yet been told what
to see in it.It's some place that we've never seen - except in that
it looks like any other Pacific island. Tourism depends on the construction
of a different and unique identity - for the benefit of those looking
in from the outside. But only when you live on Tuvalu will you experience
what makes it different from the next island. Or, to take a very
different case, only when you live in Rwanda will you understand
how the United States works. Look inside Afghanistan and you will
find a place for China.The world behind the mirror works on principles
of analogy, not congruence. Bigger is different.
Statistics
>> 15 Most and least visited countries
(from the World Tourism Organization)
>> spreadsheet analysis
World Map (as of 10_9)
>> presentation (click mouse to advance)
World Map (as of 10_17)
>> presentation (click mouse to
advance)
|